1. Contemporary Colour. Colouring varies with old maps. When they
were produced some maps were fully coloured at the time, some were
partly coloured, some were coloured in outline, and many not coloured
at all. When maps were coloured at or close to the time of production
it is referred to as contemporary colour as it is contemporary to the
printing of the map. Maps were originally coloured to enhance
appearance and readability. Generally three or four colours (green,
pink, orange and yellow) distinguished political subdivisions, black
was used for names, red coloured cathedrals or other buildings
distinguish large cities and blue stands for water.
2. Modern Colour. Often older maps issued without colour have colour
added in whole or in part. Any colour added long after the map was
issued is referred to as modern colour. Modern colour can be skillfully
applied or less so but it usually is in outline and may or may not be
historically correct. If it is skillfully applied and historically
correct it is often difficult to distinguish from contemporary colour.
If you are in doubt you can ask a map dealer. Usually they can
distinguish between the two.
3. Pros and Cons. Most dealers and collectors agree that
contemporary full colour is best and that bad modern colour is
undesirable but after that there is substantial lack of agreement. Many
uncoloured maps are much more attractive with skillfully applied modern
colour. A few collectors prefer maps only as originally issued coloured
or not but most dealers agree that skillful modern colour enhances
interest and thus value of many maps. It is very much an individual
collectors choice.
Useful references: